Selection Guidelines

Donald Duck; Walt Disney Productions Corp.

Consider the following factors when evaluating comics.

1. Popularity. Monthly lists of the top-selling comics titles are readily available in fan magazines and trade journals.

2. Tie-ins to TV shows, movies, video games, and toys. 

3. Age level, target audience, and general suitability.

4. Genre. Super-hero and fantasy titles continue to be the most prevalent and popular genres, but libraries should consider exploring science fiction, humor, realistic fiction, and other styles.

5. Writing quality, including originality of plot and characters, overall appeal, character development, dialogue, and pacing.

6. Artistic quality, including layout, dramatic impact, storytelling flow, drawing skill, coloring (where relevant), and lettering.

7. Artistic style, especially regarding distinctive styles such as manga or cartoon art.

8. Reputation of writers and artists, many of whom have strong fan followings.

9. Awards and recognition received. Major industry awards include the Eisner, Harvey, and Kirby awards. Significant annual fan awards include the Comics Buyer's Guide Fan Awards and the Usenet "Squiddies."

10. Reputation of publisher.

11. Color versus black & white. Newer readers may not be used to b&w comics.

Depiction of Women in Comics Selecting Age-Appropriate Material

back to: main page

compiled and maintained by: Michael R. Lavin, Lockwood Memorial Library
send comments to: Michael R. Lavin, mrlavin@acsu.buffalo.edu
design by: Catherine Collins, Educational Technology Center
last updated on: January 12, 2000